≡

wincent.dev

  • Products
  • Blog
  • Wiki
  • Issues
You are viewing an historical archive of past issues. Please report new issues to the appropriate project issue tracker on GitHub.
Home » Issues » Feature request #298

Feature request #298: REQUEST: Option to do "play" and "pause", but never "playpause"

Kind feature request
Product Synergy Advance
When Created 2005-09-14T04:23:35Z, updated 2006-05-05T12:20:12Z
Status closed
Reporter Greg Hurrell
Tags no tags

Description

From a pair of user emails:

----------

This isn't a bug per se, but a problem I've had with the play/pause button (or hotkey) with Synergy is that isn't the equilvalent of actually telling iTunes to play/pause, like sending iTunes a playpause command in AppleScript. Namely the disadvantage to this is that if the selected playlist in iTunes is not the playlist containing the current track, pressing the pause button in Synergy will cause the current track to stop completely, and pressing it again (with the intent to continue playing the track) will cause whatever the currently selected track is to start playing from the beginning. This is the same behavior of the play/pause/stop button in the iTunes application, but not necessarily what I'd like the Synergy play/pause button to do.

Would it be possible for there to be an option to fix this? (Seems like a relatively simple thing to do.) Perhaps an extra button in the advanced section to specify which behavior the user prefers?

----------

As it turns out, I was wrong. The iTunes AppleScript command "playpause" actually does do the same thing as the play/pause/stop button in the application itself, and as such has the same inherent problem that my previous email was about.

As far as a feature request goes, this might be pushing it, but change what I said from having the play/pause button actually send a playpause command (which is almost certainly what it already does) to running or performing the equilvalent of the following appleScript:

tell application "iTunes" if player state is playing then pause else play end if end tell

which, though it is a bit asinine, actually does pause or play the current track, no matter what the selected playlist or track in iTunes is.

Comments

  1. Greg Hurrell 2005-09-14T04:26:28Z

    Thanks for submitting the feature request. I actually consider this to be a bug in iTunes (why should the behaviour of "playpause" be different to "play" and "pause"?). Nevertheless, I agree that implementing the workaround that you propose shouldn't be too hard to do, and that it would best be an option in the advanced preferences. In the meantime if you want to file a bug report with Apple to encourage them to make the iTunes behaviour more consistent, send them feedback:

    http://www.apple.com/feedback/itunes.html

  2. Greg Hurrell 2005-09-14T04:29:18Z

    Oh, and the other thing I forgot to mention: if you want to take a peek at Synergy Advance you'll see that it allows you to define separate hot keys for "Play/Pause" and "Play" and "Pause". It's not exactly the solution you're asking for (mostly because you can't set the same hot key combination for both "Play" and "Pause"), but it is another way of working around the problem.

  3. Greg Hurrell 2006-05-04T08:18:02Z

    Ok, I've now implemented this option. Adding the fixed-in-prerelease keyword.

    To be notified when the new version is out (hopefully within the next 24 hours) please subscribe to the announcements list.

  4. Greg Hurrell 2006-05-05T12:20:12Z

    0.4 is now out. Full announcement here:

    https://wincent.dev/a/news/archives/2006/05/synergy_advance_8.php

    Marking as FIXED/CLOSED.

Add a comment

Comments are now closed for this issue.

  • contact
  • legal

Menu

  • Blog
  • Wiki
  • Issues
  • Snippets